From 2017 to 2019 I was fishing shallow water with friends and was looking for lures that floated, dove a few feet at most, and casted well with a 7.5ft bait casting rod. I bought a bunch online from Japan, was given a few, and eventually settled on 3 confidence lures not shown here. The Waxwing was one of the 3; the other two were so deadly I blurred their appearance in blog photos!
When I looked for my old lures, I found a box full of lures that didn’t make the First Team. A couple of these were fished and caught fish, while the others stayed in that box because they were too much like other lures I was fishing, or were experimental lures given to me that I never fished. Here’s a breakdown of what they are.
The Lucky Craft Sammy (top left) is one of the easiest walk-the-dog lures but this one is made out of wood and the original owner preferred the hard plastic Sammys. I’ve never fished it. The Tackle House M Quiet (upper right) is a top water lure meant to fish calm, quiet water and I did catch a kaku on it but it was light for me to cast with a bait caster.
The IMA Popkey (2nd from top, on left) with its slanted face can be walked, waked or splashed but I never got around to fishing it because the fish I was targeting in very shallow water liked very slim lures.
The Tiemco Red Pepper (left side, 2nd down) is an original wooden bodied lures, and the Tiemco Red Pepper (right side, 3rd down) is plastic bodied and customized with reflective material by the original owner. I hadn’t fished either but have fished plastic bodied Red Peppers and have gotten the most violent strikes on them if I let them bob up and down and sit in the water.
The Daiwa TD Salt Pencil F (lower right) is the reknown Daiwa Salt Pencil in a very small, light size, so it really was hard to cast far but was very deadly when pulled so the water gurgled through the cut out gills, then paused.
The Duo Tide Minnow Slim, and Maria Chase SW in the bottom right aren’t back weighted so I assumed I’d have a hard time casting such light lures with a bait caster, thus I didn’t bother to put hooks on them but I had purchased them used from eBay Japan because they were the OGs of JDM lipped lures. They are fished by straight retrieving them and pausing. Their tight wobble and small size is what gets them bit.
These are 5 inch or bigger floating lures, geared to attract larger fish so I ended up not fishing them from shore. The Daiwa SP Minnow (top) has ball bearings that roll back on the cast, so it casts well. The well known Yozuri SP Minnow (2nd from top) is a lousy caster but has a very aggressive swimming action. It’s probably better used as a trolling lure for papio. Both the Jackall Bowstick and River2Sea WideGlide have wide walk-the-dog actions and big fish potential.
Have you guys fished any of these, and how were they? Any comments on their potential? Since I still have the First Team lures somewhere, I wonder if I’ll ever fish these?
Krystal says
Very interesting read! I appreciate you sharing your notes on these. Like I said before, hard to know what you’re looking for in a lure until you try them all. I’m curious about those deadly two that you blur in pictures haha. Don’t share them! Keep that research close. Everyone should put in the time the way you do 👊
Scott says
Thanks for always being so supportive Krystal! Yeah, it took hours of trial and error to find those really dependable whipping lures, and while I’m not revealing them yet, I’m trying to find something similar that can be sold at an affordable price.
Maybe some other lure chuckers may want to share their experiences?
Wow Scott, those are some pretty good lures. I’d fish all of them except maybe that M Quiet. There are so many JDM lures in Japan that it can be overwhelming. I’ve tried a bunch and have found some favorites and some duds. Hard to go wrong with the big brands like Shimano and Daiwa. They’re always coming out with new models and discontinuing older ones. Overall they make good lures that catch fish. They often release US versions of their JDM lures but the color choices of the US versions are pretty bland. Most spots I fish are pretty shallow so I like topwater and shallow swimming lures. Other brands I like are Ima, Little Jack, and Tackle House.
Hi Thad,
Thanks for sharing your JDM expertise and experience! The Little Jack joined hard bait, and jigs I got from you are truly works of art and hard to risk getting teeth marks on! Ima and Tackle House are two of my favorite 5 Japanese brands. All 5 make a lure that is my favorite of its type.
I’ve reached out to Lucky Craft and Duo International since they distribute in the US but it’s not looking like a small dealer like me can get a dealer discount significant enough to make selling price + shipping cheap enough to compete with Amazon Prime. I was really trying to provide some really good lures for folks to try, at a low price point.
Maybe it’s time for another comparison from you, JDM vs Domestic near shore lures!
thanks,
scott
I could do a comparison but I’d have to go out and buy some Domestic lures first. Lol
Now that’s funny!! Maybe I should write the comparison, with your edits. 🙂