The people have voted, and were correct.  The fish responsible for destroying my Gulp lures were the humuhumunukunukuāpua’as.  They couldn’t get their relatively small mouth around the large weedless hook I was using so they whittled down the back of the lures like a pack of piranhas.

I’m not sure why there were so many of them at this one spot but needless to say, I moved to another spot to fish!

Thanks for participating in our first poll.